Email and calendar

How to draft email replies with AI and still check them

The short answer

Let the AI write drafts, never send, and check each in a minute for facts, promises, numbers, recipients and tone. Give it your facts and sample replies, and correct it in words when it errs.

3 min read

The one-minute review

Read every draft for these five, in this order. The first three are where the expensive mistakes hide. Every vendor warns its AI may suggest inaccurate information, so the review is not optional.

CheckLook forWhy
FactsOrder numbers, names, what happenedGaps get filled with plausible guesses
Promises"We will refund", "by Friday"You are bound by what you send
Prices and datesEvery numberOld prices, wrong year or timezone
RecipientsTo, Cc, reply-allA supplier on the thread
ToneToo stiff, cheerful or longMatters least, easiest to fix

How to draft email replies with AI, step by step

  1. Step 1: Choose which emails get drafts

    Questions from customers to support@, or all mail from people (not newsletters) to you. Narrow is better.

  2. Step 2: Drafts only, never auto-send

    Drafts in the thread, or a card to approve.

    Watch out. Turn off any auto-send setting before the first run, and check it again after every update to the tool.

  3. Step 3: Load your facts and examples

    Three real replies you liked, your exact greeting and sign-off, and the facts it will be asked about: prices, hours, policies, links. Update facts the day they change.

    Do this step in 50agents

    Set up an AI agent that reads new support emails, drafts a reply from what you know about my business, and asks me before sending

    Build it

    Captain builds an AI agent that drafts replies from your business's memory, which you can read and correct. Every reply waits for you to approve, change or decline. See the ready-made version.

  4. Step 4: Say what it must never offer

    Refunds by email, discounts, legal opinions. Give the reason, so it applies the rule sensibly.

  5. Step 5: Tell it what to do when unsure

    "If the answer is not in what you know, do not draft. Tell me what is missing." A gap you see beats a guess you send.

  6. Step 6: Review for two weeks, then decide

    Count drafts sent unchanged, edited and thrown away. Fix the facts behind the thrown-away ones.

    Tip. When you change a draft, tell the tool why in words, such as "we never offer refunds by email, offer a call".

What can go wrong

  • A promise you did not make

    The draft offered a refund or a deadline. Keep policies in the AI's facts and list what it may never offer.

  • Stale prices

    Last year's price sits in its memory. Update facts the day they change.

  • Reply-all to the wrong people

    A thread with a supplier on Cc. Check recipients every time; it takes a second.

  • Everything sounds the same

    Generic drafts come from having no examples. Paste in three of your own replies.

Questions people ask

Can AI reply to my emails for me?

It can draft them well. Sending should stay with you, at least for anything that reaches a customer.

How do I make AI emails sound like me?

Give it three replies you wrote and liked, your exact greeting and sign-off, and correct it in words when it misses.

Should I tell people a reply was drafted by AI?

If you read and approve it, it is your reply. If something goes out unreviewed, say so, or better, do not let it.

How long should checking a draft take?

About a minute. Read for facts, promises, prices and dates, recipients, then tone, in that order. The first three are where the expensive mistakes hide.

What should the AI never offer in a reply?

Refunds by email, discounts and legal opinions are the usual list. Write the reason beside each rule, so it applies them sensibly to cases you did not foresee.

When can I let it send on its own?

Count drafts sent unchanged, edited and thrown away for two weeks. Even then, keep anything with a promise, a price or a refund behind your approval.

Read next

Or let Captain build it

One sentence to Captain. Free to start.

Build it with Captain
How to draft email replies with AI and still check themBuild it