Built-in AI or an AI agent?
The four piles
| Pile | What goes in | What the AI does |
|---|---|---|
| Reply | A person asking you something | Drafts a reply in the thread |
| Read | Updates, reports, things to know | A one-line summary each |
| File | Receipts, invoices, confirmations | A label, nothing else |
| Ignore | Unread newsletters, notifications | A label you review weekly |
Four piles, not twelve. Every extra category is a decision the AI can get wrong and you have to check.
How to triage your inbox with AI, step by step
Step 1: Write your four piles in one line each
"Reply: a client or supplier asking me something. Read: reports and team updates. File: receipts and invoices. Ignore: newsletters."
Step 2: Pick the times
Once before you start (8:00) and once after lunch is plenty. Every few minutes costs more and interrupts more.
Do this step in 50agents
Go through my unread email now, then every weekday at 8:00, and draft replies
Build itCaptain builds an AI agent that goes through your unread email now, then every weekday at 8:00, drafts the replies, and asks you before any email leaves. See the ready-made version.
Step 3: Give it your voice and facts
Three sentences on how you write, your sign-off, and the facts it will need (prices, hours, links). Without them, drafts sound like nobody.
Step 4: Start with labels and drafts only
No archiving, deleting, unsubscribing or sending. You stay the one who moves mail out of the inbox.
Watch out. Auto-archive hides mail you never see. Keep everything in the inbox with labels until you trust the rules.
Step 5: Read the first week's piles
Look for anything important in Ignore. Fix the one-line rules until nothing important is misfiled for a week.
What can go wrong
An invoice in Ignore
A rule like "ignore anything automated" catches bills. Name what must never be ignored: invoices, contracts, anything from your bank.
Unsubscribed from something you needed
Do not let AI unsubscribe for you. Review the Ignore pile and unsubscribe yourself.
Encrypted or shared mailboxes skipped
Copilot cannot read S/MIME or Double Key Encryption mail, and shared mailboxes have limits. Other tools have similar gaps; check yours.
"No unread email" when there was
The tool searched for the word "unread" instead of using the unread state. Ask it to say what it searched for.
Questions people ask
Can AI manage my inbox for me?
It can sort, summarise and draft. Keep sending, deleting and unsubscribing for yourself, at least until its drafts and labels are right week after week.
Does Gmail have AI sorting built in?
Gmail has its own categories and filters, and Gemini can summarise and draft. Neither runs a scheduled pass that drafts replies before you open your inbox.
Is it safe to give AI access to my email?
Limit what it may do: read, label, draft. Every send should wait for you. Read the vendor's data terms before connecting.
How many labels should I use?
Four piles: Reply, Read, File and Ignore. Every extra category is a decision the AI can get wrong and you have to check.
How often should it sort my email?
Twice a day is plenty: once before you start and once after lunch. Every few minutes costs more and interrupts more.
What if something important lands in Ignore?
Look through Ignore during the first week, and fix the one-line rule for that pile. Keep going until nothing important is misfiled for a week.